I will protect your pensions. Nothing about your pension is going to change when I am governor. - Chris Christie, "An Open Letter to the Teachers of NJ" October, 2009

Wednesday, April 24, 2013

How Every Kid Could Go To Bill Gates's Private School

There are times when I'm not sure that even EduShyster could parody the musings of Bill Gates. For example:
After almost two decades of pursuing improvements in U.S. education through the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation, Gates maintains a sweeping and grand ambition. His goal for the next 20 years, he says, is to graduate roughly twice as many kids from college, move the United States up in the international rankings, and do so without spending more money. It's as if Gates wants to apply a version of Moore's law (in which the number of transistors that can fit on an integrated circuit double every two years) to education. 
Gates: In K-12, we're in an era where, unfortunately, we're not going to be able to increase the amount of resources, because state budgets are tight and medical costs are constantly increasing. So can we get more out of $600 billion a year? No Child Left Behind [the annual testing program started in 2002] let us know that we weren't doing very well. But it was fairly minor in terms of identifying particular ways of solving the problem. [emphasis mine]
First of all, maybe we could do something about those medical costs. You know, like the rest of the industrialized world, which spends far less than we do and gets better results?

There are roughly 300 million people in the US, and we spend about $8,200 on each for health care. If we could cut that back to about $4,900 - which would still make us #4 in health care spending - we'd save about a trillion dollars. Hold that thought...

Second, maybe we should consider taxing people like you more Bill. After all, you and your fellows at the very, very top are taking more of the money:

While paying historically low effective tax rates.

So, Bill, we could - if you'd allow us - greatly decrease our health care costs and greatly increase our revenue collections. What could we do with all of this money?

Here's a thought: you send your own kids to your high school alma mater, the Lakeside School in Seattle.  Tuition at Lakeside is $27,250 a year - and that's not even spending per pupil, because it doesn't include gifts and endowments. Further, Lakeside doesn't educate the children with severe or even moderate learning disabilities, or for whom English is a second language, or are autistic, or have severe physical disabilities, or who live in poverty. 

Contrast this to the average $11,467 we spend on each public school child.

Right now we spend about $570 billion per year on public education. Which means it would take about a trillion more dollars a year to get the per pupil spending for public school children close to the level that the Gates children enjoy (and that's a very conservative estimate). 

A trillion dollars... oh, yeah, what we could save on health care and still be #4 in per capita spending! And that wouldn't even cost you a penny; imagine how much more we could do if we started taxing you at higher rates...

I'd rather not...

ADDING: If you haven't watched this yet, do yourself a favor:


Regan said...

oh man.....

Michael Fiorillo said...

Let's also not forget that the 1% derives most of its wealth from capital gains, not income, so their tax rates are even lower than they appear.

alm said...

We spend almost that much per student in Camden and Newark, but nobody would compare those school systems to Lakeside School.

Equitable school funding is a precondition - and NJ and the Ed Law Center have done heroic work on that front. Take Newark - depending on how you count it, the budget is ≈ 1 billion for ≈ 40,000 students. And somewhere north of 85% of that comes from supplemental State or Federal sources.

It's inspiring -- the system really does work to reduce inequities for NJ's most needy.

The world that you're asking for exists. We have it in Newark and Camden. But are we going to make it a reality? Everyone - Cami, Cerf, principals, teachers - needs to step up to the plate and make real on that promise.

Melissa Westbrook said...

I live and write a public education blog in Seattle. Yes, it is challenging living in a small region with multiple billionaires (Microsoft, Amazon, Starbucks, etc.). But Gates casts a very big shadow and it's hard to stop. (We did come within 42k of votes to defeat charter schools for the 4th time.)

But his children will never know large class sizes and yet he says class size doesn't matter.

Lakeside IS very different from public school but he likes to act as through it's available to all.

And, the ed wing of the Gates Foundation has had few successes despite spending millions.

ravitrellis said...

nice post thanks for sharing this with usPlay School in East Anand Bagh
Preschool in East Anand Bagh

Green Gables said...

At Green Gables, we believe education is a natural ‘give and take’ where we learn as much from children as they from us; that our children transform us as we transform them.
Best Pre Primary Schools in Hyderabad
Best Kids Schools in Madhapur
Secondary Schools in Hyderabad

ravitrellis said...

Great post. I used to be checking continuously this weblog and I’m inspired!Very helpful information particularly the ultimate part :) !
Secondary Schools in Hyderabad

ravitrellis said...

Thank you a lot for sharing this with all of us you actually realize what you’re talking approximately! Bookmarked. Please also discuss with my site

Best Kids Schools in Madhapur